GRE

This author’s argument is not cogent because it is rife with holes and misinterpretation of facts .Also it is based

GRE Essay Topic 948 - Milk and dairy products are rich in vitamin D and calcium, substances essential for building and maintaining bones. Many people therefore believe that a diet rich in dairy products can help prevent osteoporosis, a disease in which the bones weaken significantly with age and that is linked to both environmental and genetic factors. But a long-term study of a large number of people has found that those who have consistently consumed dairy products throughout the years of the study have a higher rate of bone fractures than any other participants in the study. Since bone fractures are a symptom of osteoporosis, this study result shows that a diet rich in dairy products may actually increase, rather than decrease, the risk of osteoporosis. Discuss how well reasoned you find this argument.

Author: Prachi_11 | Date: January 24, 2014 | Score:4 | => 5 or 6 Essays, Click Here <=

This author’s argument is not cogent because it is rife with holes and misinterpretation of facts .Also it is based

This author’s argument is not cogent because it is rife with holes and misinterpretation of facts .Also it is based on a study whose scope and validity are quite questionable .Therefore use of this study to come up with the given argument does not prove to be a good case .Author’s him selves agrees that the disease in consideration is a result of both environmental and genetic factors .This factors have clearly not been taken into account while performing the study.

Furthermore it may be the case that the study was conducted on large number of people of a single area whose environmental conditions favored osteoporosis. Bone fractures can happen due to plethora of reasons .To consider only one of the reason i.e. diet is quite constraining and produces wrong results .Again fractures are not the only symptom of osteoporosis .It could have happened that people not having dairy products in their diet may have shown some other symptoms perhaps even more noticeable .

Showing symptoms and actually having a medical condition are quite different because symptoms can be caused by other factors as well .So even though people showed symptoms doesn’t necessarily mean that they are suffering from the disease. It is a given fact that dairy products strengthens bones, therefore author is quite wrong to consider only some of the facts to reach a conclusion.




  • [Score & Analysis]


    Under the same topic

    Dairy products and bone fractures Score: 4.5 July 2nd, 2018 by Paras Avkirkar
    At the beginning, author argued for benefits of dairy products in preventing osteoporosis. Later she described a particular study and its observations, concluding that a diet rich in dairy products...Read more
    Milk and dairy product Score: 4.5 October 22nd, 2017 by fred
      In this argument ,the arguer concludes that a diet rich in dairy products may increase,instead of decreasing the risk of osteoporosis,alluding that we should limit the consume of such products ...Read more
    Milk and dairy products are rich in vitamin D and calcium Score: 5 March 30th, 2016 by findscore.com
    For years, doctors, parents, and educators have emphasized a daily balance of nutrients to maintain health. Moreover, they have stated milk and dairy contain essential vitamins that help strengthe...Read more
    The assumption provided by the author that the diet rich in dairy product and milk decreases the risks of osteoporosis Score: 4.5 September 26th, 2015 by findscore.com
    The assumption provided by the author that the diet rich in dairy product and milk decreases the risks of osteoporosis are vague and unsubstantiated. The long term study did not mention about the t...Read more
    Vitamin D Score: 4 November 19th, 2014 by findscore.com
    In this argument, the author posits that although milk and dairy products are reputed to be conducive for precluding osteoporosis, evidence indicates that the connection between the disease and con...Read more
    This article claims that having diet in which dairy is rich could have negative impact on osteoporosis. However, it relies Score: 5 June 2nd, 2014 by findscore.com
    This article claims that having diet in which dairy is rich could have negative impact on osteoporosis. However, it relies on some unsubstantiated assumptions which render it to be unconvincing. Th...Read more

    Leave a Comment